*Turkish
reforms fall short of EU standard, critics say
Changes to ease torture, do little for free speech
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By Amberin Zaman
Special To The Sun
February 10, 2002
ANKARA, Turkey - A set of long-delayed reforms aimed at bolstering Turkey's
chances for membership in the European Union will help reduce widespread
torture but do little to expand freedom of expression, human-rights advocates
and opposition lawmakers said Thursday.
The package of constitutional amendments was passed by the 550-member
parliament Wednesday despite tough resistance from the ultra-nationalist
wing of Turkey's three-party coalition government, whose members said the
reforms would encourage Kurdish separatists and other enemies of the state.
Husnu Ondul, chairman of Turkey's Human Rights Association, said the
changes would drastically improve human rights in four Kurdish-dominated
provinces where most abuses occur. Those four provinces are governed by
emergency laws.
Under the new law, the maximum number of days detainees accused of so-called
terror crimes can be held without trial was reduced to seven.
Previously, anyone accused - often with scant evidence - of sympathizing
with rebels of the outlawed Kurdistan Workers' Party, better known as the
PKK, or of committing other terror offenses could be held indefinitely
without access to a lawyer. As a result, hundreds of prisoners are languishing
in jails across the four provinces.
Emergency rule was introduced throughout the southeast region to help
quell a separatist insurgency launched in 1984 by the PKK to establish
an independent Kurdish state.
Rebels declared a unilateral cease-fire after the capture in 1999 of
their leader, Abdullah Ocalan, and an atmosphere of relative peace prevails.
As the PKK began to scale down its attacks, the Ankara government started
phasing out emergency rule throughout the Kurdish regions.
Turkey became the first predominantly Muslim nation to be added to the
EU's list of official candidates in 1999. The country's poor human-rights
record and its refusal to grant its estimated 12 million Kurds greater
cultural rights are cited among the chief reasons Turkey has so far not
been admitted.
Ondul said in a telephone interview that most of the reported abuses
occur during pretrial detention and that reducing the length of that period
also will reduce torture. "It's a huge improvement," he said.
But critics say the reforms do not go far enough. They cited laws against
insulting or defaming the Turkish state, which remain on the books even
though the latest reforms reduce the maximum jail term from six years to
three years.
"The broad interpretation of the law will continue to result in scores
of academics, journalists and politicians being prosecuted and jailed for
expressing dissenting views," said Nevzat Toroslu, head of Ankara University's
Penal Law Department.
"The interpretation of the laws is left in the hands of the judges,
and as long as the mentality of the judges does not change, there cannot
be progress," Toroslu said.
Amberin Zaman wrote this article for the Los Angeles Times, a Tribune
Publishing newspaper |